Sundae Afternoon Menu

Flavors

Flavors subject to availability

Cups & Cones

Cup & Cone Options & Sizes

Waffle Cone: +$1.10
Chocolate-Dipped Waffle Cone: +$1.30
Chocolate-Dipped Waffle Cone with Nuts: +$1:50
Sprinkle & Chocolate-Dipped Waffle Cone: +$1.50

Single Scoop: $4.75
Double Scoop: $6.25
Triple Scoop: $7.25

Toppings

Price Per Topping

Sprinkles: +$0.50
Chocolate & Rainbow

Candy/Nut Toppings: +$1.00
Mini M&Ms, Mini Reese’s Pieces, Kit Kat, Heath Bar, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Chocolate Chips, Gummy Bears, Crushed Oreos, Peanuts, & Walnuts

Sauces & Syrups: +$1.00
Hot Fudge, Caramel, Peanut Butter, & Marshmallow

Fruit Toppings: +$1.00
Strawberries & Pineapple

Sundaes

Includes one sauce, one topping, whipped cream & a cherry!

Build Your Own Sundae: $7.50
Specialty Sundae: $9.50
Apple Pie a la Mode, Bear Attack, Cookie Lover,
Ice Cream Ambrosia, Peanut Butter and Fluff,
Peanut Butter Lover, S'mores

Super Specialty Sundaes: $10.75
Kitchen Sink, Not Quite Banana Split

Novelties

Donut Ice Cream Sandwich: $6.50
Made with Neil’s Donuts,
filled with chocolate, vanilla or coffee ice cream

Ice Cream Bomb: $6.50
Strawberry Shortcake, Toasted Almond, or Chocolate Eclair

Ice Cream Sandwiches: $6.50
Classic Ice Cream Sandwich or
Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich

Waffle Taco: $6.50
Homemade waffle cone filled with vanilla fudge swirl ice cream, dipped in chocolate

Drinks

Small Milkshake: $5.75
Large Milkshake: $7.00
With any ice cream listed above!

Ice Cream Float: $7.00
Root Beer, Coke or Orange Soda

Bottled Water: $1.50
Lemonade: $1.75
Soda: $1.75
A&W Root Beer, Coke, Polar Dry Orange

Dog Ice Cream

Doggy Afternoon Delight: $3.50
Low fat vanilla ice cream topped with
peanut butter and mini dog treats

Ice Cream Cakes

Ice cream cakes available in store (subject to availability)!

Classic Ice Cream Cake:
6” Cake (Serves 4-6): $25
9” Cake (Serves 12-15): $32
Vanilla and Chocolate

Custom Ice Cream Cake: Prices Vary
Made to order; please contact us or fill out this form.

Pinata Ice Cream Cake:
6” Cake (Serves 4-6): $30
9” Cake (Serves 12-15): $36
An ice cream cake filled with your choice of candy!
Made to order; please contact us or fill out this form.

To order, please email sundaeafternooncakes@gmail.com and title your email, “Cake Order,” in the subject line, or please call ( 203 ) 269 - 4207.